fbpx

SIGN IN YOUR ACCOUNT TO HAVE ACCESS TO DIFFERENT FEATURES

FORGOT YOUR PASSWORD?

FORGOT YOUR DETAILS?

AAH, WAIT, I REMEMBER NOW!
QUESTIONS? CALL +1 321.222.6822
  • LANGUAGES
    • LOGIN

    ABA Technologies, Inc.

    ABA Technologies, Inc.

    Experts in the Science of Behavior Analysis.

    T +1 321.222.6822
    Email: info@abatechnologies.com

    ABA Technologies
    930 South Harbor City Blvd., Melbourne, FL 32901

    Open in Google Maps
    • Our Founder
      • The Celebration of an Amazing Life: Jose Martinez-Diaz (1950–2020)
    • ABA Online
      • Registered Behavior Technician Training
      • BACB Exam Prep
    • Professional Development
      • On-Demand Continuing Education Courses
      • The 21st Century BCBA Supervision Course Series
      • OBM Specialist
      • The Exceptional Supervisor Certificate
    • Resources
      • Do the Right Thing:
 a Discussion with Tom Freeman
      • Infographics
      • Videos
      • Timeline
      • Press Releases
      • eBooks
        • Telehealth eBook Free Download
    • Blog
    • Podcast
    • About
      • Our Mission
      • Our Team
      • ABA Tech Careers
        • Careers
        • Concentrated Supervised Fieldwork
      • Contact
    • Store
      • ABA ONLINE PROGRAM
      • BOOKS
        • From Boo-Hiss to Bravo: Performance Scorecards People Will Use and Like
      • RBT ESSENTIALS TRAINING 2.0
      • OBM CERTIFICATE PROGRAM
      • BACB MOCK EXAMS
      • FUN PRODUCTS
    • MY CART
      No products in cart.
    ContactUs
    • Home
    • Blog posts
    • Time for a Timeout from Timeouts?
    April 18, 2021

    Time for a Timeout from Timeouts?

    0
    Andy Lattal
    Andy Lattal
    Tuesday, 08 January 2019 / Published in Blog posts

    Time for a Timeout from Timeouts?

    Guest Blogger: Andy Lattal, Ph.D.

    In a recent article published in the Washington Post entitled, “Timeouts are a dated and ineffective parenting strategy. So what’s a good alternative?” the author of the article answers the question of the present blog affirmatively. She states, “I never used timeouts with my older kids and I don’t plan to rely on it when the baby I’ll give birth to in a few weeks is old enough to go into full-blown tantrum mode.”

    Breakdown Between Behavior Analysis and General Audiences

    Everyone benefits from reviews of current practices in any human endeavor and so it is with this article. When I consider my question, even (and maybe especially) after reading the Post critique, my answer differs from the article’s author. But debating perceived shortcomings of timeouts is not the point I wish to address. What concerns me more is the recurring breakdown in communication between behavior analysis and general audiences. I don’t wish to point fingers as to whether it is “them” or “us” who is at fault (probably a little of both), but rather how overgeneralization and categorical statements lead to confusion and to more problems than they solve.

    The Post article notes that “[t]imeout involves placing your child in a designated quiet, isolated, safe place in the home immediately after they’ve ignored a warning to stop misbehaving. After a brief explanation for why they’re in timeout, the child sits there long enough to calm down and think about what they’ve done wrong.” This pretty much follows the technical definition a behavior analyst might offer—a response-dependent, time-limited removal of the opportunity for positive reinforcement. Timeout is a generic term that has spilled over into the mainstream through various sources, including the TV Supernanny noted in the article. Unfortunately, “treatments” that don’t meet this definition also are labeled as timeouts. On the one hand, in extreme examples of the latter, children have been banished to a “timeout closet” or other locations for unreasonable periods of time. Not only is this beyond the pale of either of the above definitions of timeout but is beyond the pale of anything bordering on the reasonable treatment of others. Such examples rise to the level of child abuse. The actions of those responsible should be reviewed for possible criminal charges.

    Appropriate Examples of Timeout

    On the other hand, appropriate examples of timeout cover a range of procedures within the definition offered above, with “time-limited” being critical to the definition. One such example is that of ignoring an inappropriate remark by a child (or an adult). Such behavior, part of the normal human social discourse, would be suspect if the article author’s recommendation of the categorical avoidance of using timeouts were followed literally. These variations underline the problem of lumping together under the same label techniques with very different forms and outcomes. Behavior analysts are noted for their precision in both language and in the application of techniques. With its categorical dismissal of a timeout, and labeling all timeouts as “unacceptable,” the author allows for none of the nuances familiar to behavior analysts in defining or using timeouts.

    As for the functioning of timeouts, the author notes that “[a]s far as I have seen, [timeout] has varying, unpredictable results.” There are at least two problems with this statement. First, relying on anecdotal evidence is one of the first things professionals in any field are taught not to do. Her statement is categorical and flies in the face of a lot of empirical evidence to the contrary. None of these data are mentioned. Second, when a well-established technique like timeout doesn’t work, one has to ask “why not?” Categorical dismissal of its effectiveness is unjustified without considering the circumstances under which it is shown to be ineffective. The parent who says “I’ve tried timeout and it doesn’t work” may be in the same category as the parent who says “I’ve tried positive reinforcement and it doesn’t work.” One can imagine, for example, a scenario where a child is sent to her room for a timeout, only to discover the space selected for the timeout is laden with things that may be more enjoyable than the circumstances that landed the child in “timeout” in the first place. The point is that in evaluating statements about the use of any behavior-management technique one must ask the right questions about circumstance and context under which the putative technique is being used. This isn’t mentioned in the article.

    Opinion Does Not Translate As Fact

    In place of timeouts, the author cites several family therapists and psychiatrists who support her contention that the proper way to address children’s behavior is by sitting down and talking with them, rather than using timeouts. Sitting down and talking with children is hard to argue with, but, from my perspective, so are well-placed, judiciously used timeouts. Talking with children as a means of management is as contextual as any other child-rearing technique. Both talking and timeout probably have their place in the management of human behavior. Categorical, overgeneralized dismissal of one or the other based on no evidence or anecdotal evidence seems remiss and a disservice to caregivers often desperate to help their children.

    There are, of course, other reasons to dismiss even techniques for which there may be empirical support of their effectiveness. What one considers personally as ethical or unethical, moral or immoral, however, must be placed in the context of others’ values and those of society more generally when prescribing or damning treatment options. Opinion, which is what the article is, does not translate as fact. It isn’t so much time for a timeout from timeouts as it is for a timeout from overgeneralization and categorical rejection of proven behavior-management methods. And as for talking to that two-year-old in “full-blown tantrum mode”? Good luck.


    Learn More About Arranging Reinforcement Systems in Applied Settings


    REGISTER NOW

     


     

     

    • Tweet
    Tagged under: Parenting, Positive Reinforcement, Response-Dependent, Timeout

    What you can read next

    ABA Tech and Florida Tech Launches the 2nd Edition RBT Course
    21st Century Supervision Skills for Behavior Analysts
    Like a Boss

    3 Comments to “ Time for a Timeout from Timeouts?”

    1. Agency and Shaping - ABA Technologies, Inc. says :Reply
      August 13, 2019 at 2:25 pm

      […] blog posts by Andy Lattal, Time for a Timeout from Timeouts?, and Operant Behavior and […]

    2. Behavior in Translation - ABA Technologies, Inc. says :Reply
      November 26, 2019 at 2:12 pm

      […] Time for a Timeout from Timeouts […]

    3. Immedium and Procrastinium: A Fable in Waiting - ABA Technologies, Inc. says :Reply
      January 7, 2020 at 11:51 am

      […] Time for a Timeout from Timeouts […]

    Leave a Reply Cancel reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

    Recent Posts

    • Rear view of unified diverse people huddled up.

      Actively Caring for Our Country

      Guest Blogger: Mackenzie Davis What does it mea...
    • Guiding the Role of the RBT

      How Supervisors can Positively Impact Progress ...
    • header Actively Caring for People Policing

      Actively Caring for People Policing: Building Positive Police/Citizen Relations by E. Scott Geller & Bobby Kipper Book Review

      ​Guest Blogger: Megan Diamond Given the interna...
    • Organizational-Behavior-Management-Jobs-OBM

      What do OBM Professionals Do

      OBM Series Guest Blogger: Vince Bello, ABA Tech...
    • BSA-Behavioral-Safety-Analysis_header

      Behavioral Systems Analysis: OBM Series

      Guest Blogger: Vince Bello, ABA Technologies CS...

    Categories

    • Blog posts
    • Ethics Q&A
    • Infographics
    • Press Releases

    CONTACT ABA TECHNOLOGIES, INC.

    Please complete this form and we'll get back to you as soon as possible!

    MENU

    • ABA Online
    • Blog
    • Professional Development
    • Store
    • About
    • News & Resources
    • Terms and Services
    • Privacy Policy
    • Sitemap
    • Operant Innovations Podcast

    NEWSLETTER SIGNUP

    By subscribing to our mailing list you will always be update with the latest news from us.
    We never spam!

    GET IN TOUCH

    T 1 321 222 6822
    Email: info@abatechnologies.com

    ABA Technologies
    930 South Harbor City Blvd, Melbourne, FL 32901

    Open in Google Maps

    over a year ago#obmapplied #bcba #bcaba #qanda #instructor #professionaldevelopment #professionaldevelopmentprograms https://t.co/OQk6r9if0a
    Follow @abatechnologies
    • Tweet
    • GET SOCIAL
    ABA Technologies, Inc.

    © 2020 All rights reserved.

    TOP
    This site uses cookies to provide you with a more responsive and personalized service. By using this site you agree to our use of cookies.
    Close
    Terms of Service

    Privacy Overview

    This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. Out of these, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. But opting out of some of these cookies may affect your browsing experience.
    Necessary
    Always Enabled

    Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. This category only includes cookies that ensures basic functionalities and security features of the website. These cookies do not store any personal information.

    Non-necessary

    Any cookies that may not be particularly necessary for the website to function and is used specifically to collect user personal data via analytics, ads, other embedded contents are termed as non-necessary cookies. It is mandatory to procure user consent prior to running these cookies on your website.

    SAVE & ACCEPT